🔗 Share this article

According to several government insiders, China has reportedly threatened to retaliate against the UK if ministers move to designate specific elements of its intelligence infrastructure under recently established external lobbying disclosure rules.

Bilateral Tensions Intensify

Chinese representatives reportedly conveyed this warning to the Foreign Office shortly following reports emerged that the UK government was considering such actions. This situation has heightened alarm bells given the government's ongoing hesitance to apply stricter external lobbying rules on advocates representing Beijing or any segment of the PRC government.

Current Lobbying Disclosure System

At present, exclusively the Russian Federation and Iran have been included in the stricter tier of the external lobbying registry (Firs), which came into effect in the summer and was fully implemented this month. This framework mandates anyone in the UK representing a external government or entity to declare their operations to the authorities or risk criminal sanctions.

• The stricter tier applies to nations and organizations deemed a significant threat.
• It requires additional reporting above the basic obligations.
• Consequently, anyone conducting unregistered work on behalf of Tehran or Moscow could receive up to five years in prison.

Potential Designations

Previously, reports indicated that rather than targeting Beijing as a whole, ministers were considering including certain parts of the PRC governmental structure that have been accused of meddling in western nations to the stricter tier.

Such entities reportedly include:

• The PRC's primary intelligence agency
• The CCP (CCP)
• Beijing's united front apparatus
• The People's Liberation Army (PLA)

Dismissed Espionage Trial

Meanwhile, the government is under increasing scrutiny over the recent collapse of an spying trial against two Britons, including a ex- legislative aide. Christopher Cash, a former legislative assistant to Conservative MPs, and his friend the second defendant had been accused of working on behalf of China.

Their trial was unexpectedly dismissed by the public prosecution authority in the autumn. Both defendants had contested the allegations.

Legal Complications

Journalistic accounts indicated that the government's unwillingness to officially characterize Beijing as an "enemy" in witness evidence from a security official led to the trial's dismissal. Jonathan Powell, the prime minister's top security official, allegedly chaired a discussion in the UK government headquarters where he informed officials that the government's testimony would avoid labeling Beijing an adversary.

Government sources subsequently denied the claim that the security adviser was involved in restricting government evidence.

The judicial complication stemmed from the espionage legislation of 1911, which specifies that a individual is guilty of spying if they pass on information "directly or indirectly useful to an enemy". Yet, the present administration's security policy describes Beijing as a "strategic competitor" rather than an enemy.

Continuing Diplomatic Relations

Notwithstanding these disagreements, UK-China diplomatic ties appear to be warming. Several senior UK officials have visited China on official visits since the new government took office. Among them are Peter Kyle, who participated in commercial discussions last month, and Jonathan Powell, who visited during the summer.

Additionally, talks have supposedly occurred between senior Foreign Office officials and parliamentary leadership regarding the prospect of removing the ban on the Chinese ambassador accessing parliament, potentially in return for Beijing lifting its sanctions on UK parliamentarians.

The UK leader Keir Starmer is widely expected to make a bilateral trip to China in the beginning of the new year, though the specific schedule might be influenced by global developments, including a potential trip by ex-American leader Donald Trump.